3P Security GroupPrevent · Protect · Preserve
Consulting · Available now

Vendor selection and bid review

We write one scope for your bidders, then compare their responses against its lines. You receive a reusable scope, a comparison matrix, questions for each firm and a review of contract terms.

What the comparison checks

Scope lineWhat we compare in the responses
Hours and postsThe coverage each bidder has priced
Supervision and turnover coverThe work included in each bid
Reporting and insuranceThe stated requirements and limits
Rate changes and exitThe contract terms affecting later costs

These are review categories from our scope, not findings from a completed bid review.

Fig. A

Where the difference between quotes actually hides

BID ABID BBID C Hours and post count Supervision not priced Turnover cover not priced not priced Reporting not priced Insurance limits Rate escalator not priced not priced One scope, so the quotes answer the same questions.
BID A B C Hours and posts Supervision Turnover cover Reporting Insurance limits Rate escalator Crossed means that bidder never priced the line.

How it runs

  1. Define what you are buying. Posts, hours, supervision, reporting, cover for turnover, insurance limits and how the rate moves in year two.
  2. Issue one scope. Every bidder receives the same document so the responses can be laid side by side.
  3. Read the responses. Compare each response against the scope and identify unpriced lines for questions.
  4. Sit in on the decision. We can be on the call when you pick, or stay out of it. We are not one of the bidders.

What you receive

  • A written scope of work you own and can reuse at the next renewal.
  • A comparison matrix with bidders against the scope lines, including omissions.
  • Questions to ask each firm before signing, with what a good answer should cover.
  • A review of contract terms covering escalators, cover and exit.

We take no referral fee, no commission and no manufacturer margin on anything we recommend.

This is consulting on work you buy from providers.

Compare your bid prices

Enter your annual post-hours, each bidder's bill rate and additional annual charges for matching work.

Annual bid total = annual post-hours x bill rate + additional annual charges.

Price difference = bid B total - bid A total.

Bid A annual totalEnter your numbers
Bid B annual totalEnter your numbers
Price differenceEnter your numbers

Match duties, supervision, relief, insurance and calendar assumptions first. An unpriced item stays unknown until the bidder answers. Use separate lines where rates differ.

This service starts at $1,000 per property. A first conversation costs nothing, and the fee for anything past that is fixed and written into the scope of work before any work starts.

The other consulting services

Check a vendor with the Chapter 1702 buyer's guide.